10 Factors to Consider: Experiential Campaigns vs. Digital Advertising
"Marketing Experts - How do you decide when to invest in an experiential campaign versus digital advertising?"
Here is what 10 thought leaders had to say.
Balance Experiential and Digital for Maximum Impact
Selecting between experiential and digital marketing comes down to your goals. Need customer trust or emotional lifestyle indexing? Go experiential. Need a fast pace and instant digital results? Digital wins. I recommend clients utilize both. Use an experiential event that helps emphasize the emotional memory, then use digital retargeting to spread the message.
For example, a luxury car company does exclusively booked test drives as an experiential marketing event. They then retargeted with digital ads based on the experiential click-throughs (personalization). In short, experiential marketing creates the stories, and digital marketing delivers them to the right audience.
Eric Sornoso, Co-founder, Mealfan
-------------------------------------------
Build Trust First with Boots on Ground
If I'm trying to drive awareness in a market where people don't know the brand, I go straight into experiential. I don't mean pop-ups for the sake of it. I'm talking about getting into the neighborhoods, setting up mobile units, and giving people a chance to actually use the product in context. For a service like locksmithing, people need to see the speed, understand the tech, and know there's a human side to the business. You can't do that with static ads. You're asking for trust, and that starts with presence.
When we launched in Broward County, I remember people being unsure about what we actually did. So I set up mobile stations at car washes and strip malls with heavy foot traffic. We brought the tools, demoed digital key programming live, and let people ask questions. That was the turning point. We didn't pitch them. We showed them. That gave our digital campaigns a foundation. After that, retargeting actually meant something because people already knew who we were.
If you skip that early engagement and go straight to digital, you end up paying for impressions that don't move. You get clicks, but no conversion. So I always ask myself such as, are we still introducing ourselves here, or are we reinforcing? If we're still introducing, then we start with boots on the ground. That is what sets the tone. Only after that do I put real money behind ads, because then the market is warmed up and ready to listen.
Eli Itzhaki, CEO & Founder, Keyzoo
------------------------------------------
Match Marketing Strategy to Customer Journey Stage
As a marketing expert, the decision to invest in an experiential campaign versus digital advertising comes down to the goal of the campaign, the stage of the customer journey, and the emotional depth needed to create brand impact.
If the goal is awareness, emotional connection, or building community engagement—especially for product launches or rebrands—experiential campaigns are highly effective. They allow people to interact with your brand in a sensory, memorable way. For example, when launching a new line of IT prep tools at Clearcatnet, we opted for a hybrid experiential model by hosting a virtual "Certathon"—a live 3-day event with workshops, giveaways, and real-time support. It created buzz, generated content, and strengthened brand trust among certification aspirants.
On the other hand, if the goal is scaling quickly, lead generation, or remarketing, digital advertising is the go-to. It's measurable, scalable, and ideal for targeting specific audiences at different funnel stages. We lean heavily into Google Ads, LinkedIn, and YouTube when we want to drive traffic, retarget previous visitors, or promote specific certification dumps.
The best approach is often integrating both. Use experiential campaigns to fuel emotional momentum and user-generated content, then amplify that engagement through digital ads to drive traffic and conversions. My advice: Let the desired outcome and audience behavior guide your investment—not just budget or trend.
Kaushal Kishor, CEO, Clearcatnet
-------------------------------------------
Create Memories Offline, Amplify Them Online
It all comes down to what you're trying to achieve—and how deep you want the connection to be.
I typically lean into experiential campaigns when the goal is to build community, brand affinity, or cultural relevance. If you want people to feel something, remember it, and talk about it organically, real-world experiences still win. They create moments that digital just can't replicate—especially when combined with content capture that feeds your online presence afterward.
On the other hand, digital advertising is perfect when you need scale, precision, and performance. If your goal is conversions, lead gen, or A/B testing creatives in real time, digital is the more agile and data-driven route.
That said, the magic often happens in the middle:
- Use experiential to create emotion.
- Use digital to amplify it.
The best campaigns I've seen start offline, then live forever online. So I always ask: Is this a moment I want people to scroll past—or a memory I want them to keep? That usually points me in the right direction.
Okan Uckun, Tattoo Artist / Founder, MONOLITH STUDIO
-------------------------------------------
Digital Gets Clicks, Experiential Drives Lasting Conversions
The reaction I want from the audience. When I want the audience to feel, I choose experiential. When I want them to do something, I choose digital advertising.
Let's say we want more visits to a product page, sign-ups for newsletters or to drive purchases. In this case, we will go digital. It is fast, measurable and quantifiable if the goal is clear.
When we want something deeper than a transaction, say brand affinity, loyalty or understanding, we invest in experimental campaigns. The audience will feel a sense of responsibility, rich history, a part of a community and the joy of a safe space with our brand.
Digital advertising gets you the clicks while experiential campaigns drive conversions. Unfortunately, clicks fade over the weeks or months and moments last.
Sam Jacobs, Head of Marketing, Ammo.com
-------------------------------------------
Digital Tests Messages, Experiential Makes Them Stick
Deciding between experiential campaigns and digital advertising comes down to timing and goals. If the goal is immediate traction, message testing, or optimizing CAC, digital is the clear choice. It’s fast, measurable, and easy to adjust. So digital works well when precision matters, like launching a new product, refining messaging, or reaching specific demographics. It acts like a live testing ground, helping shape what resonates before scaling up.
Experiential is about long-term brand impact. It works best when the brand already has a strong identity and wants to create emotional connection. Because a well-executed activation can reshape how people talk and think about a brand, which is tough to do through digital alone. But it’s higher risk, more expensive, harder to measure, and only effective when there’s something meaningful to say.
So these aren’t competing channels. They serve different purposes. Digital helps figure out what messages land. Experiential makes those messages stick. The decision depends on where the brand is in its journey and what outcome is needed at that point.
Josiah Roche, Fractional CMO, JRR Marketing
-------------------------------------------
Experiences Build Believers, Digital Drives Traffic
For me, the decision to invest in an experiential campaign over digital advertising comes down to one core question:
"Do we need deeper connection or wider reach right now?"
If the goal is mass visibility, fast conversions, or testing new offers — digital advertising wins every time. It's scalable, measurable, and flexible enough to pivot on short notice. But if we're launching a premium offer, nurturing high-trust relationships, or building brand loyalty in a saturated space? That's where experiential makes sense.
Here's a real example: When we launched a high-ticket group coaching program, we skipped ads and ran a curated virtual experience for hand-picked leads. Think exclusive Zoom roundtable, real-time coaching, surprise gifts delivered to their door. Cost per lead was higher — but the conversion rate hit 38%, and nearly every attendee became a long-term client.
The key is knowing your growth stage.
Digital drives traffic. Experiences build relationships.
Sometimes you need both — but if you're trying to create brand believers, not just buyers, experiential marketing is where the magic happens.
Lisa Benson, Marketing Strategist, DeBella DeBall Designs
-------------------------------------------
Test with Digital Before Investing in Experiential
I treat experiential like a luxury, not a starting point. I've seen too many brands spend 30 or 50 grand on a pop-up or fancy event before they've even tested if anyone cares about their offer. It might look good on Instagram, but it doesn't drive leads if the message isn't right.
I always test with digital first. Run paid ads, email, socials. If no one clicks or replies, the idea is dead. I'm not spending a cent turning it into a live event unless it's already getting traction.
Experiential only works when people already trust you. If the connection is there, sure, build on it with something they'll remember. But if the offer isn't landing, you're just spending for content and hoping it works.
Digital is how I test. Experiential is how I build on what's working. Doing it the other way around is just a gamble.
Nirmal Gyanwali, Founder & CMO, WP Creative
-------------------------------------------
Blend Digital Precision with Experiential Connection
The decision to go experiential vs. digital comes down to how deep you need to connect with your audience—and where they are in the buyer journey.
At Simply Be Found, we lean into digital advertising when the goal is scalable visibility, local discovery, and driving immediate actions like calls, clicks, or direction requests. Platforms like Google and Facebook allow us to reach the right audience fast, especially for small business clients who need measurable ROI.
But when we want to build trust, brand recall, or long-term loyalty, that's when we consider experiential strategies—especially at local events, workshops, or community pop-ups. These campaigns help us humanize our brand, gather real-time feedback, and create emotional connections that digital alone can't replicate.
Here's how I frame the decision:
Go digital when you need precision, performance data, and direct response.
Go experiential when you want to spark conversations, tell stories face-to-face, or launch something that needs emotional stickiness.
The most powerful campaigns? Blend both. For example, we'll sponsor a local business meetup (experiential), then retarget attendees online afterward with educational ads tied to what we taught. That way, your brand doesn't just show up once—it becomes memorable.
Robert Downey, Co-Founder, Simply Be Found
-------------------------------------------
Math Should Drive Your Marketing Channel Mix
I always start with the math. Just like in SEO, you can model your total acquirable market before committing to an experiential campaign. I lean toward in-person investment when high-value audiences are better reached directly and search volume is too low to justify digital spend.
Experiential works best when attention is concentrated more than it is scalable. As generative AI shifts how users discover information online, brand visibility through curated, real-world interactions may only grow in value. This is exactly the right time to be reevaluating the mix.
James DeLapa, SEO & Web Strategy Expert, Bottom Line Insights
